Last Updated on July 22, 2025 by PuterMan
First of all let me clarify what I mean by a mega-quake. For the purposes of this exercise I take a mega-quake to be any quake over 8.5 magnitude, generally on the Mw scale. Roughly speaking this is earthquakes with energy of ~0.4 Exajoules (354813389233559.0 Kilojoules) or greater.
Secondly, what follows here is my opinion only and you should not under any circumstances take actions, or fail to take actions, with regard to safety and/or preparedness as a result of what you read here.
Download “Will there be another mega-quake in 2011” as a PDF file.
The earthquakes I will look at are found on this list from the USGS as it happens. Largest Earthquakes in the World Since 1900
I will look at a period of 1 month before the earthquake and 18 months after the earthquake. I will also look for up to -2 Magnitudes. There is a theory around that you can expect an aftershock of 1 magnitude below the main shock after an earthquake and this is accepted in geological circles. I aim to show that this cannot be said of the larger earthquakes – the mega-quakes. Unless otherwise stated my data is drawn from the USGS Centennial Catalogue.
Note that the world’s 10 largest earthquakes as this used to be has now become 16. This is partly because of reclassifications and of course because of Tohoku.
Click the image or the link above if you think a quake is missing. Some revisions have been made which are noted on the USGS page.
For those who wish to get the quick answer here is the cheat link to the conclusion.
Chile 9.5
May 22nd, 1960. The largest earthquake in the world so far.
The parameters for this are from ‘1960-04-22’ to ‘1961-10-22’ Mag > 7.5
This results in just 3 lines worldwide after the event of < 2 magnitudes below, which do not qualify for the maxim as they are under Mag 8.5
Note the 2 fore-shocks.
Prince William Sound Alaska 9.2
March 28th, 1964. The largest earthquake in America so far.
The parameters for this are from ‘1964-02-28’ to ‘1965-09-28’ Mag > 7.2
This results in 13 lines worldwide after the event of < 2 magnitudes below, which do not qualify for the maxim as they are either under Mag 8.2 and thus do not class as mega-quakes or are not aftershocks to the main shock.
Whilst there was an 8.2 it cannot be considered an aftershock as it was in the Banda Sea, Indonesia.
Off the West Coast of Northern Sumatra 9.1
December 26, 2004. The most destructive quake in terms of loss of life.
The parameters for this are from ‘2004-11-26’ to ‘2006-06-26’ Mag > 7.1
The centennial catalogue does not cover this time span so I created a dataset with information from ANSS. 17 earthquakes were returned from the ANSS search
* catalog=ANSS
* start_time=2004/11/26,00:00:00
* end_time=2006/06/26,23:59:59
* minimum_magnitude=7.2
* maximum_magnitude=10
* event_type=E
One earthquake qualifies as an aftershock within 1 mag of the main shock, but it could be argued that this is an earthquake in it’s own right as it is in the list above – Sumatra – and it is on a different plate. If it is a separate earthquake and not part of the Banda Aceh earthquake then the maxim fails. In this instance however either way a mega-quake occurred within 12 months of another.
Kamchatka 9.0
November 04, 1952.
The parameters for this are from ‘1952-10-04’ to ‘1954-05-04’ Mag > 7.0
9 earthquakes in the centennial including the main shock.
Nothing making the grade here on either count but the last one would not have made it as an aftershock as it is in a completely different area.
Offshore Maule, Chile
February 27, 2010.
The ANSS catalogue had to be used for this one.
The centennial catalogue does not cover this time span so I created a dataset with information from ANSS. 15 earthquakes were returned from the ANSS search. Looking at 7.3 upwards now as 6.8 will just produce too many and the maxim is up 1 magnitude.
The parameters for this are from ‘2010-01-27’ to ‘2011-08-27’ Mag > 7.0
* catalog=ANSS
* start_time=2010/01/27,00:00:00
* end_time=2011/08/27,23:59:59
* minimum_magnitude=7.3
* maximum_magnitude=10
* event_type=E
Of course the time is not up on the 18 months for this one however the Tohoku earthquake in Japan falls just outside the year I am looking at. None of the other quakes are qualfiers for the maxim either.
Off the Coast of Ecuador 8.8
Jan 31st, 1906
Back to the centennial for this one.
The parameters for this are from ‘1905-12-31’ to ‘1907-07-31’ Mag > 7.3
16 earthquakes returned including the main shock. None of them qualify as mega-quakes or aftershocks within the 1 magnitude.
Rat Islands, Alaska 8.7
February 4th, 1965
If you look at the Prince William Sound list above you will see this earthquake listed as a Magnitude 7.8 in the centennial catalogue. I then looked at the ANSS catalogue and the results are shown below.
Your search parameters are:
* catalog=ANSS
* start_time=1965/01/01,00:00:00
* end_time=1965/03/31,23:59:59
* minimum_magnitude=7.3
* maximum_magnitude=10
* event_type=E
DateTime,Latitude,Longitude,Depth,Magnitude,MagType,NbStations,Gap,Distance,RMS,Source,EventID
1965/02/04 04:53:57.70,51.1000,178.4000,40.00,7.75,Unk,37,,,0.00,NEI,1965020440
1965/03/14 15:53:06.60,36.3000,70.7000,219.00,7.50,Unk,54,,,0.00,NEI,1965031440
1965/03/30 02:27:07.20,50.6000,177.9000,51.00,7.30,Mb,26,,,0.00,NEI,1965033040
As you can see this earthquake is listed as a 7.75 which is close enough to 7.8 in the centennial catalogue.
However, the other entries in the centennial do show the earthquake as an 8.7 Mw
7.5 M GSX
8.7 Mw P&S
8.2 Ms ABE1
8.2 Ms P&S
8.7 Ms ISC
7.7 mB ABE1
8.1 UK B&D
6.1 mb ISC
The M1 magnitude, the preferred magnitude, is given as 7.8 therefore for the purposes of this exercise I must stick by the rules and only use the M1 value from the centennial, thus I exclude this quake from the list. In fact the USGS are not playing by the rules including this one. Bear in mind later however that this quake if counted as 8.7 means there was a mega-quake within one year of Prince William Sound.
Northern Sumatra, Indonesia 8.6
March 28th, 2005
If we are to take this as an earthquake in it’s own right then it has no mega-quake following and no qualifying aftershocks.
Assam – Tibet 8.6
August 15th, 1950
Back to the centennial for this one. The parameters for this are from ‘1950-07-15’ to ‘1952-02-15’ Mag > 7.4 I have cut back the range of magnitudes a bit more as we get lower down the scale but this is still showing more than 1 magnitude below the main shock.
10 earthquakes including the main shock found and none of them qualify as mega-quakes or as aftershocks in the 1 magnitude band below the main shock.
Andreanof Islands, Alaska 8.6
March 9th, 1957
The parameters for this are from ‘1957-02-09’ to ‘1958-08-09’ Mag > 7.3
Applying the rules here the M1 value is still shown as 9.1. If you look at the USGS page you will see a note that it has been reclassified. The M2 value is 8.6Mw. Which ever value you take however there is no mega-quake and no qualifying aftershock.
Southern Sumatra, Indonesia 8.5
September 12th, 2007
* catalog=ANSS
* start_time=2007/08/12,00:00:00
* end_time=2009/02/12,23:59:59
* minimum_magnitude=7.3
* maximum_magnitude=10
* event_type=E
The 7.9 just after the main shock is definitely an aftershock and thus we have a qualified aftershock in the 1 Mag range. There is no mega-quake within 12 months. The 7.9 marked in blue is discounted as it is 800 Km away on a different plate.
Banda Sea, Indonesia 8.5
February 1st, 1938
The parameters for this are from ‘1938-01-01’ to ‘1938-08-01’ Mag > 7.3
No qualifying aftershocks or mega-quakes.
Kamchatka 8.5
February 3rd, 1923
The parameters for this are from ‘1923-01-03’ to ‘1924-08-03’ Mag > 7.3
No qualifying aftershocks or mega-quakes.
Chile 8.5
November 11th, 1922
The parameters for this are from ‘1922-10-11’ to ‘1925-05-11’ Mag > 7.3
The Kamchatka earthquake above qualifies as a mega-quake occurring with 12 months of another. There are no qualifying aftershocks.
Kuril Islands 8.5
November 11th, 1922
The parameters for this are from ‘1963-09-13’ to ‘1965-03-13’ Mag > 7.3
This earthquake has a qualified aftershock inside the 1 magnitude range. There is also the 1964 Prince William Sound earthquake as a qualifying mega-quake. It could almost be considered that this 8.5 was a fore-shock to that one.
So putting this all together what do we have? (In descending order of Magnitude)
Basically on historical evidence it would seem that there is a greater possibility of there being an earthquake within 1 Magnitude of the main shock of a mega-quake, and of another mega-quake occurring within a year in Alaska and the volcanic archipelago, and on the opposite side of the Pacific plate in Indonesia, whereas elsewhere in the world the chances of either are very slim indeed. Obviously the result of the Japan earthquake is not really in yet as a year has not passed but it would seem that a further mega-quake in this year is unlikely. I believe it is also unlikely that there will be a mag 8 in the Honshu area.
The aftershock maxim almost certainly seems likely to apply to scenarios where the main shock is not a mega-quake. (Maybe this bears some investigation?)